HomeDigital Resource LibrarySocial StudiesLabor Movements & Protest Music during the Industrial Era

Labor Movements & Protest Music during the Industrial Era

Arts Integrated Lesson Plans and Materials for Teaching the Industrial Revolution & Grades 9-11 Social Studies

Jump to topic: Lyrical Substitution

Create a Song Using Lyrical Substitution

Pairs with Social Studies, Grades 9-11

Students explore how music has been used to unite social movements—particularly the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW)—by closely analyzing historical texts and songs, and then applying this technique by writing new lyrics to familiar melodies that represent workers’ struggles during the Industrial Revolution.

Z

Standards

Z

Getting Ready

Z

Downloads

Z

TEACH!

Z

Creators

SOCIAL STUDIES

  • USH.BR.1 – Students will analyze the causes and consequences of industrialization in the late 19th-century United States by:
    • Evaluating how improved use of resources, new technology and inventions, and transportation networks influenced the growth of industrialization and urbanization. (USH.BR.1.a)
    • Describing the impact of business leaders, laissez-faire capitalism, and the use of trusts/monopolies on the American economy. (USH.BR.1.b)
    • Evaluating the impact of industrialization and laissez-faire policies on labor. (USH.BR.1.c)

COMMON CORE STATE STANDARDS

  • RH.9‑10.2 – Determine central ideas or information in a source and summarize key developments.
  • RH.9‑10.3 – Analyze events or ideas in detail to understand causes, effects, and relationships among them.
  • W.9-10.3.d – Use precise words and phrases, telling details, and sensory language to convey a vivid picture of the experiences, events, setting, and/or characters.
  • RH.11‑12.7 – Integrate multiple sources and formats (text, song, primary documents) to answer questions or solve historical problems.

ARTS STANDARDS

  • MU:Cr1 – Generate and conceptualize artistic ideas and work
  • MU:Re7 – Perceive and analyze artistic work
  • MU:Cn11 – Relate artistic ideas and works with societal, cultural, and historical context to deepen understanding

CONTENT TOPIC

  • Industrialization

ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS

  • Did the benefits of post-Civil War industrialization outweigh the costs?

OBJECTIVE

  • Students will analyze how songs promoted worker solidarity in historical movements like the IWW and create their own protest song using lyrical substitution from the perspective of a worker during the Industrial Revolution.

ASSESSMENT

  • See slides for rubric, criteria breakdown, & examples
  • Students will work in small groups to create a protest song using a familiar melody and lyrics that reflect a challenge faced by workers during the Industrial Revolution. Each group will compile their song into a one-page songbook, including:
    • A visually engaging cover with the song title
    • A page with a slogan or message (can be designed like a logo)
    • A page with the full song lyrics

MATERIALS & CLASSROOM SETUP

KEY SOCIAL STUDIES VOCAB

  • Note: A complete glossary can be found on the Industrial Workers of the World Handout.
    • Labor Union
    • Industrial Workers of the World (IWW)
    • Solidarity
    • Strike
    • Direct Action
    • Industrial Revolution
    • Protest Song
    • The Little Red Songbook

KEY ARTS INTEGRATION VOCAB

  • Lyrical substitution: Writing your own lyrics to the melody of a well-known song.

STUDENT BACKGOUND & PRIOR LEARNING

TEACHER BACKGROUND & PREPARATION

Watch: Meet Dan & Claudia Zanes
Watch: Music, Solidarity, and the IWW: How Songs Unite Movements

Dan & Claudia explain how the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) used inclusive organizing and collective singing—through adapted popular songs—to build worker solidarity and galvanize social movements during the Industrial Revolution.

Watch: From Spirituals to Protest Songs: Examples of Lyrical Substitution

In this video, Dan & Claudia show how familiar Spirituals were transformed through lyrical substitution into powerful Civil Rights protest songs, demonstrating how music unites movements and supports collective action.

Watch: Assessment Overview: Songbook Criteria & Model Song with Songbook Example

Return to Topic

Printable Version

Video Playlist

Slides

Concept Map

ENGAGE

Music, Society, & You

Slide 2: Opening discussion – (turn & talk, stop & jot, and/or whole class):

    • Your opinion: Music can create real change in society.
      • Why or why not?
    • Have you ever had a song get stuck in your head that made you feel understood or less alone?
      • What made it powerful — the lyrics, the beat, the message?
      • Did it change how you felt in the moment?

Say: Today we’re going to see how workers turned shared feelings into shared action—using music.


BUILD BACKGROUND

What was the Industrial Revolution & the IWW?

Slide 3: Explain the objective & assessment

    • Objective: Students will analyze how songs promoted worker solidarity in historical movements like the IWW and create their own protest song using lyrical substitution from the perspective of a worker during the Industrial Revolution.
    • Assessment: Students will work in small groups to create a protest song using a familiar melody and lyrics that reflect a challenge faced by workers during the Industrial Revolution. Each group will compile their song into a one-page songbook, including:
      • A visually engaging cover with the song title
      • A page with a slogan or message (can be designed like a logo)
      • A page with the full song lyrics

Slide 4: Discuss & research to build background knowledge & context

Slides 5 & 6: Share photos of The Little Red Songbook (primary source)

    • Zoom in to read the table of contents and the preamble

LEARN

Music, Solidarity, and the IWW – How Songs Unite Movements

Slide 7: Students watch Dan & Claudia’s informational video where they make the connection between the time period, the IWW, and music

Slide 8: Understand the concept of lyrical substitution

    • Share the definition and a simple example with students:
      • Lyrical substitution: Writing your own lyrics to the melody of a well-known song.
      • Example: Original (familiar melody): Twinkle, twinkle, little star
        • Original lyrics:
          • Twinkle, twinkle, little star / How I wonder what you are
        • Substituted lyrics (same melody):
          • Working long days, no time to rest / Factory work is such a test

Slide 9: Students watch Dan & Claudia’s informational video, “From Spirituals to Protest Songs: Examples of Lyrical Substitution.”

Slide 10: In pairs, students practice the skill by writing their own lyrics to an existing melody:

A) Write lyrics about what you’ve learned about the Industrial Revolution and the IWW to the tune of “Twinkle, Twinkle.”

B) Write lyrics about what you’ve learned about the Industrial Revolution and the IWW to the tune of a well-known song of your choosing

C) Write lyrics about _____ (teacher/student choice) to the tune of “Twinkle, Twinkle” or another well-known song of your choice.


APPLY

Write a protest song & create a songbook

Slide 11: Review the assessment

    • Assessment: Students will work in small groups to create a protest song using a familiar melody and lyrics that reflect a challenge faced by workers during the Industrial Revolution. Each group will compile their song into a one-page songbook, including:
      • A visually engaging cover with the song title
      • A page with a slogan or message (can be designed like a logo)
      • A page with the full song lyrics

Slides 12 & 13: View Dan & Claudia’s Example

    • Slide 12: Hear their song, “Shine Bright in the Union” to the tune of Rihanna’s “Diamonds.”
    • Slide 13: See their songbook example with modeling of cover, logo, and lyrics

Slides 14 & 15: Review assessment criteria & rubric

    • Can be adapted to your class structure and student needs

Students work in groups to craft their songs

    • Instruct students to first select the existing song they will use to rewrite lyrics about the workers of the Industrial Era. You may have a pre-selected list for students to choose from, or allow groups to choose their own songs (teacher discretion surrounding original lyrics appropriate for school advised).
      • Students research songs to find and note original lyrics
      • Students refer to notes and research to begin writing their lyrics. Guiding questions can include:
        • Whose point of view are you writing from?
        • What challenges are they experiencing?
        • What is daily life like for them?
        • Use sensory details and figurative language to create imagery about what they see, hear, taste, smell, and feel daily.

Next, create songbooks

    • Once students have their lyrics completed (check them first for accuracy and understanding), groups create their songbooks, including the engaging cover, the logo/slogan, and printed lyrics. Traditional art supplies like colored pencils and paper can be used, or digital options like Canva.

Perform & share!

  • Encourage student groups to share their songs with the class and for peers to provide positive feedback.

EXTENSION (OPTIONAL)

    • Class book: Compile all class songs into one songbook to make your version of The Little Red Songbook!
    • Write a song about an issue important to me: Once the students are comfortable with this assignment and have written their song about issues facing workers in the Industrial Revolution, students can write a song about an issue that’s important to them today using lyrical substitution.

Return to Topic

Materials Google Folder

ROOT BRANCH MEDIA GROUP – BRING ROOT BRANCH TO YOUR SCHOOL!

All video content made in partnership with Baltimore’s Root Branch Media Group.

DAN + CLAUDIA ZANES  BRING THE ZANES TO YOUR SCHOOL!

Haitian-American jazz vocalist and music therapist Claudia Zanes and Grammy Award winning all-ages entertainer Dan Zanes have been making music together since the day they met in 2016. During their time together the two have toured extensively; written and performed Night Train 57: A Sensory Friendly Comic Folk Opera for the Kennedy Center; created House Party: A Family Roots Music Treasury songbook for Quarto Publishing Group; and released their first record as a duo, Let Love Be Your Guide, for Smithsonian Folkways. Their follow-up Folkways album, Pieces of Home, was released in August, 2024. Vocals! Guitar! Flute! Percussion! Trombone! Harmonica! Jaw Harp! Dan and Claudia bring their social electric folk music with them wherever they go. People attend the highly interactive concerts knowing they’ll be singing along and dancing to a sound that lies at the center of Haitian folk, early rock and roll, sea shanties, Black gospel and blues. Learn more at https://danandclaudia.com/.